In the relentless world of the NBA, reputation often precedes performance. In many cases, the star power a name carries prevents up-and-coming talent from showcasing their impressive skill set, regardless of their form. Even in the twilight of his career, Paul George is still a renowned force in the league, but with Justin Edwards rekindling a fire that established him as an unlikely star during his rookie year, does the veteran forward warrant a return to the Philadelphia 76ers' starting lineup?
Paul George is expected to be available for selection on March 25 against the Chicago Bulls when his 25-game suspension for violating the NBA's anti-drug policy is over. George's return will not only alleviate the strain the depleted roster is currently under, but it will also provide much-needed experience and leadership on both sides of the ball.
Before his suspension, the 35-year-old was finally finding comfort in his less prominent offensive role on the 76ers. George appeared to set aside his ego and deliver some crucial contributions on the defensive end of the floor. Despite allowing the play to flow through the hands of Tyrese Maxey and Joel Embiid for the most part, George is still averaging 16 points, 5.1 rebounds, and 3.7 assists per game.
What George can offer the team should never be debated; his resume speaks for itself. The real dilemma revolves around meritocracy -- if a player is excelling in his absence, shouldn’t he deserve to keep his place in the starting lineup?
Justin Edwards' development deserves to be rewarded
Despite struggling to rediscover his rookie form at the start of the 2025-26 campaign, Justin Edwards redoubled his efforts behind the scenes and is now reaping the rewards of his hard work. Being patient for an opportunity is never easy for a professional athlete at the top of his trade, yet Edwards' journey as an undrafted prospect has provided him with a never-say-die attitude that resonates with the City of Philadelphia.
In the absence of the 76ers' star trio, Edwards has found himself at the forefront of the team's offensive game plan and has excelled in this role. Over his last five appearances, the Kentucky alum has recorded 19 points, four rebounds, and 3.2 assists per game, with a career-high 32 points coming in Philadelphia's 139-118 victory over the Sacramento Kings.
Of course, the true reality of where Justin Edwards' abilities lie will come when the Sixers' star players return to action. Can he still affect winning when in a different role on the court? If Embiid and Maxey are playing, Edwards' responsibilities will alter and require him to increase his work off the ball. Setting screens and maintaining proper floor spacing can be demanding, but both will be crucial to this team’s success -- this is most likely what head coach Nick Nurse will require of him.
Paul George’s experience and recent performances suggest he can fill this role effectively and make a positive impact. However, should Justin Edwards' recent breakout result in him being provided the opportunity to prove himself even when George is available for selection? Nick Nurse has done little to provide evidence that he is willing to opt for a younger player who is thriving over an already established star.